+717 359 5040
815 Hickory Road, Littlestown, PA 17340


An elegant, exquisitely decorated wedding cake created by Karen Rodkey will be the perfect complement for your wedding day! Each cake is prepared using only the finest ingredients. From cupcakes and mini pastries to tiered cakes with cascades of fresh or sugar flowers, these cakes are the perfect finishing touch to your special day. Karen has been creating unique cakes for unique celebrations for over 20 years.

Karen Rodkey Cakes is located in Littlestown, Pennsylvania, just south of historic Gettysburg. We’re centrally located and close by to Hanover, York, and Harrisburg, Pennsylvania. We’re a short drive from Baltimore, Westminster, and Frederick, Maryland.

Wedding Cakes
Cupcakes & Mini Pastries
Groom's Cakes
Special Occasions

PRICING Cake Flavors




Starting at $5.00 per serving.

  • Chocolate
  • Yellow
  • Marble
  • Spice
  • White
  • Red Velvet
  • Almond Pound
  • Lemon Pound
  • Orange Pound
  • Vanilla Pound
  • Confetti Cake



Starting at $5.50 per serving.

  • Chocolate Chambord
  • Yellow Chambord
  • White Chambord
  • Lemon Chambord
  • Chocolate Ganache
  • Boston Creme
  • Lemon Blueberry
  • Carrot with Cream Cheese
  • Yellow with Passion Fruit
    or Peach Mousse Filling
  • Hazelnut with Mocha Butter Cream
  • Lemon Poppyseed with Lemon Filling
  • Chocolate with Peanut Butter Filling
  • Molasses Marble with Caramel Filling
  • Margarita
  • Snickerdoodle
  • Blackberry Almond
  • Cookies & Cream



Starting at $6.00 per serving

  • Tiramisu-Toffee
  • Pumpkin Spice
  • Strawberry Shortcake
  • Italian Cream Cake
  • German Chocolate
  • Sun-kissed White Chocolate
    Raspberry Cheesecake
  • Vanilla Lemon Berry
  • Hummingbird – Banana, Pineapple & Pecan
  • S’mores
  • Orange Ambrosia
  • Apple Cinnamon
  • Vanilla or Chocolate Caramel Toffee Crunch
Buttercream wedding cake with fresh flowers and silver leaf accents.
Wedding cake with sugar flowers and Chocolate Ganache, Lemon Chambord, and Apple Cinnamon cupcakes. #karenrodkeycakeswedding #weddingcupcakes
Classic all buttercream wedding cake for a late December wedding. #karenrodkeycakes
The perfect wedding cake for  New Year's Eve.  Classic black, gold, and white theme. #karenrodkeycakes
Countdown to the last three wedding cakes for 2022. #karenrodkeycakes
Buttercream iced wedding cake with fondant ribbons and fresh roses and calla lilies. #karenrodkeycakes
Two tier birch bark wedding cake with Carrot and Black Forest cupcakes. #karenrodkeycakes
Smooth iced buttercream wedding cake with fresh flowers.#karenrodkeycakes
Wedding cake iced in half vanilla  buttercream and half chocolate ganache.  Accented with cascades of handmade sugar  leaves. #karenrodkeycakes
Wedding cake with sugar flowers and Chocolate Ganache, Lemon Chambord, and Apple Cinnamon cupcakes. #karenrodkeycakeswedding #weddingcupcakes
Foral topped cupcakes!
#karenrodkeycakes #floralcupcakes #pastelcupcakes #weddingcupcakes
Holiday decorated cupcakes!#karenrodkeycakes
Delicious flavors of cupcakes- Apple Cinnamon, German Chocolate, Vanilla Caramel Toffee Crunch, & Vanilla Lemon Berry. #karenrodkeycakes
Light lavender birthday cake with wafer paper butterflies 🦋 and coordinating "hydrangea" topped cupcakes. #karenrodkeycakes
Two tier birch bark wedding cake with Carrot and Black Forest cupcakes. #karenrodkeycakes
Cupcake and wedding cake display with Strawberry 🍓  Shortcake, Carrot, and Yellow with Peach cupcakes and mini Confetti and Chocolate cupcakes 🧁. #karenrodkeycakes #cupcakedisplay#rusticwedding
Peacock theme birthday cake and cupcakes. #karenrodkeycakes #peacockcake
Antler groom's cake
Groom's cake for a groom with a fondness for snapping turtles.#karenrodkeycakes
"Trout" Groom's cake. #karenrodkeycakes
Birchbark wedding cake with my homemade gingerbread bride and groom with sugar pinecones and holly.  #karenrodkeycakes
"Bleeding Heart" groom's cake and red and black iced cupcakes. Perfect for this Halloween themed reception. #karenrodkeycakes
"Semi-naked wedding cake & Birch bark groom's cake with fresh berries #karenrodkeycakes
Wedding and Groom's cake this past weekend, sage green ruffling, gold sequins, and sugar flowers. Soccer ball groom's cake with Jamaican flag accent.#karenrodkeycakes
Chevy Camaro Groom's Cake! #chevycamaro #groomscake #carcake
Baby shower cake with adorable sugar animals. #karenrodkeycakesspecial 
"Rookie of the Year" first birthday cake with chocolate fondant covered football with sugar paste stars.
"Happy Birthday Dad" and by the way, you're going to be a grandfather!  With handmade sugar paste stork.  #karenrodkeycakes
50th birthday cake with sugar paste flowers and number. #karenrodkeycakes  #50thbirthday #50thbirthdaycake
"Beetlejuice, Beetlejuice, Beetlejuice!" Includes sugar baby carriage,  rattle, sand worm, and flying bats. #karenrodkeycakes  #beetlejuicecake #beetlejuicebaby
"Octonauts" birthday cake.  I think Liam will love it! #karenrodkeycakes  #octonauts 
Rainbow themed birthday cake.  Even the inside layers were six different colors.  #karenrodkeycakes #rainbowcake
"Where the wild things are" 1st birthday cake. #karenrodkeycakes
Chocolate Ganache birthday cake with chocolate dipped 🍓 strawberries and chocolate curls. #karenrodkeycakes
Harry Potter themed baby shower cake.  #karenrodkeycakes

SET UP A PRIVATE TASTING Call or Email today!

815 Hickory Road
Littlestown, PA 17340


.cata-page-title, .page-header-wrap {background-color: #e49497;}.cata-page-title .page-header-wrap .pagetitle-contents .title-subtitle *, .cata-page-title .page-header-wrap .pagetitle-contents .cata-breadcrumbs, .cata-page-title .page-header-wrap .pagetitle-contents .cata-breadcrumbs *, .cata-page-title .cata-autofade-text .fading-texts-container { color:#FFFFFF !important; } #cata_custom_heading_tnqvmrytx0 > h6, #cata_custom_heading_tnqvmrytx0 > h6 a{} #cata_custom_heading_q880p2g4qh > h6, #cata_custom_heading_q880p2g4qh > h6 a{} #cata_custom_heading_f7lf9o98s0 > h6, #cata_custom_heading_f7lf9o98s0 > h6 a{} #cata_custom_heading_tfzf3ipoit > h6, #cata_custom_heading_tfzf3ipoit > h6 a{} #cata_pricetable_44lpyshcbj .ptable-content{ background-color: #ffa0a0; } #cata_pricetable_x5sib0um35 .ptable-content{ background-color: #ffffff; } #cata_pricetable_ikkbx531bn .ptable-content{ background-color: #ffffff; }